Fall Frost Season Draws Nigh

Oct 2, 2020

It's now October so that means that we're now in the time of year where we start to wind down our gardens for the season. If you're at all like me and refuse to plan for the eventual coming cold weather by pulling out plants, a killing frost will force the matter.

For most of the Eastern Sierra, at least places where gardening is feasible, October brings us our first frost of the season.

I am often asked about first and last frost dates for various communities. The good news is I have that information. The bad news is that there is wide variability in the actual date. That means it's important to keep an eye on the weather forecast.

Average First Frost Dates

There are two ways to think about frost dates. Here is the first and conceptually easiest to understand: Average first frost date along with an estimate of the spread of when that might happen. The table below shows the average first frost of fall and a range of dates that shows where there is about a 70% chance the the real frost date will fall.

First Fall Frost Dates



Typical Frost Window

(≈70% Chance)  

Town Average Date

Std. Deviation

(± days)

Early Late
Independence & Lone Pine 11/3 14 10/20 11/17
Bishop (Airport) 10/13 13 9/30 10/26
Lee Vining 10/11 13 9/28 10/24
Topaz Lake 9/21 30 8/22 10/21

Big Pine is about the same average date as Bishop—maybe a little later—but it varies much more. We don't have any data, but that's a observation from gardeners there. 

It's also worth noting that the data for Topaz Lake isn't that great, and the station isn't in the best location for predicting effects to your garden. That said, the whole area has a lot of variation every year, making predictions hard. This data is a good place to start.

A Probability Approach

The other way to look at frosts is to consider some level of risk that you are comfortable and then check which date corresponds with that risk level for your location. The Western Regional Climate Center has extensive data and risk projections for many locations in California. (Here is the data: https://wrcc.dri.edu/summary/Climsmcca.html )

Below is an example for Bishop, California.

Graph of frost predictions for fall.
 
Essentially this chart tells a grower something like: There is a 60% chance of a freeze of 32°F on or before October 14. This system is much more useful for planning, but I'll be the first to admit it's easier for most gardeners to just think about average frost dates and call it good. 
 
The Western Regional Climate Center has this information for many locations. Here's how to find it:
  1. Follow the link to WRCC's page
  2. Choose a station from the list
  3. On the left side you will see various reports. Fall 'Freeze' Probability will generate a report like above. Scroll down some to see it. It's under the Temperature heading.
There are similar tables for spring's last frost and overall growing seasons as well. Lots of cool data to explore!

Final Thoughts

No matter what method works best for you, knowing more about your location's growing environment is useful to gardeners.
 
Knowledge of frost dates can help you choose when and what to plant. It also helps with deciding whether you want to frost protect in order to extend the fall season. Most gardeners just try to harvest what they can before a killing frost, but if it's an unseasonably early frost, it may be worth covering the garden at night to get a few more weeks in.

By Dustin Blakey
Author - County Director / Farm Advisor